Anthony Volpe’s Yankees Future in Doubt After Challenging Season

The 2025 MLB season has been a trying one for Anthony Volpe, casting a long shadow over his future with the New York Yankees. Once heralded as a cornerstone for the franchise, Volpe’s performance has raised serious questions, leading to speculation that the Yankees might consider parting ways with their young shortstop in the offseason.

Offensive Struggles Plague Young Shortstop

Volpe’s offensive numbers have fallen significantly below expectations. His OPS (on-base plus slugging) stands at a dismal .665, while his .269 on-base percentage (OBP) is the worst in the American League. These struggles have led to a diminished role in the Yankees’ lineup, a stark contrast to the promise he showed upon his arrival in the big leagues.

The 24-year-old’s offensive woes are a major concern for a team with championship aspirations. As one rival executive reportedly told ESPN, “What seemed like a safe bet for the future now looks like a change that could leave the Bronx sooner than expected.”

Defensive Woes Add to the Pressure

While his bat has faltered, Volpe’s defense hasn’t provided much solace. He has committed more errors than any American League shortstop except Elly De La Cruz, further fueling doubts about his long-term reliability at a crucial position. The Yankees pride themselves on solid defense, and Volpe’s struggles in the field only intensify the scrutiny.

Who Could Replace Volpe? Yankees Explore Alternatives

With the postseason looming and the need for immediate adjustments, the Yankees are actively exploring alternatives at shortstop. One name that has emerged is Jose Caballero, whose more solid defensive profile is particularly appealing to the team at this critical juncture of the season. Caballero could potentially take over the starting role if Volpe is benched or traded.

However, the market for shortstops is not without its challenges. While players like Bo Bichette might be available, his defensive capabilities raise similar concerns to Volpe’s. The Yankees’ front office faces a difficult decision: should they “sell low” on a former top prospect, or continue to invest in his development despite his current struggles?

Contractual Considerations and the Path Forward

Beyond his on-field performance, Volpe’s contractual situation adds another layer of complexity. He will be eligible for arbitration after this season, which could lead to a salary increase in 2026 without offering the Yankees any long-term guarantees. This lack of security could accelerate a potential change of scenery, especially if the team aims to revamp its roster for a new championship window.

At just 24 years old, Volpe still possesses considerable potential and room for growth. However, the Yankees, a franchise with a storied history and high expectations, are not known for their endless patience. While no official confirmations have been made, Volpe’s name is expected to be a central topic of discussion once the World Series concludes. The decision made regarding his future could significantly impact the team’s trajectory in the coming years.

The Yankees’ pursuit of another championship has been a consistent theme, and the performance of key players like Volpe is under constant scrutiny. For more on the team’s ongoing season and other MLB news, visit MLB.com.